The i525 offers a noticeable snappy feel and greater margin for error on mis-hits along with a slight increase in distance. The iron is an attractive prospect for the competent player who wants to rekindle the speed of yesteryear, or any average handicapper who likes the look of a compact player at address with long, consistent carry distances.
- Offers a feeling of liveliness
- Impressive carry distance
- Will suit a range of abilities
The D9 Forged is a powerful and impressive iron that works across the board, delivering tight dispersion with competitive distance and a smooth, solid feel. The flight is a bit low, but the trajectory consistency of a small but powerful iron means the call hits a wide range of handicaps.
- Looks stunning in the bag
- Offers a soft yet lively feel
- Tight dispersion
- Slower swingers may find it hard to get off the ground
Ping i525 vs Wilson D9 Forged Iron: Read our head-to-head verdict
There are a number of factors to consider when deciding on a new set of irons for average handicappers, including striking a balance between being forgiving and playable without looking big or bulky.
Ping is known for making some of the best golf irons on the market, with the new i525 ranking among the best Ping irons in recent times. Another brand that has a rich heritage in irons is Wilson, who have more recently produced some of the most forgiving irons as well as the best game-improving irons for your bag.
In this comparison test, we pit the underrated Wilson D9 forged iron against the Ping i525 and evaluate the look, feel, sound, distance and forgiveness so that if you are a low or medium handicap golfer at looking for a new top quality set. , you know which one is best suited to your game.
Image 1 of 2
One of the most important aspects is the look of the irons and with the Ping i525 it gets a less reflective satin finish, which we actually preferred slightly over the gloss finish of the Wilson. In addition to the finish, the darker sweetspot at address frames the ball very well. During setup we found that the extra grooves in the playing position are evident, with the shaping of the i525 remaining very traditional for a Ping iron.
When it comes to the Wilson D9 Forged, you’ll instantly notice that this is a sleek, premium iron from every angle. It’s similar in size and offset, but has a slightly thicker topline, more rounded toe, and a mirror chrome finish that we think makes the face less easy to see at address.
The Ping may just edge it out in the looks category, but the Wilson holds its own when it comes to feel and sound at impact, with a better balance of liveliness and softer acoustics across the face, giving it the advantage.
In testing, we found the D9 Forged to have a more forged feel. What we mean is that the shots seemed to stay on the face a bit longer, which will be more of a preference for lower handicap players.
We’ve always liked the sound and feel of the i525s, but they offer a more clicky metallic sound at impact that’s also a bit louder than the Wilson, which probably won’t be to everyone’s taste. While some may prefer the extra power feel it creates, which translates to distance, low handicap players considering an iron like this may want something softer.
There isn’t much between these two irons in the distance department. The Ping edges it by 1 mph in ball speed on the face and a yard or two in terms of carry distance. In our testing, the i525 featured a slightly longer shaft length, which will be a contributing factor.
The main difference however was in the flight, with the Ping hitting shots arguably in a better window for stopping power, something most golfers will be looking for as they try to hold the greens when attacking the skittles.
The D9 Forged isn’t short by any means, but it does fly the ball a bit lower meaning it doesn’t quite carry the ball as far as the i525 and hits hit the greens a bit warmer and flatter. But in testing it produced about 300 rpm more which should help keep the ball in the air and stop it on the greens but overall the Ping i525 produced performance more playable on mid and long iron approach shots.
Even professionals sometimes struggle to hit the middle of the clubface, so it’s crucial that there is some forgiveness to back up missed shots. Certainly with the i525s there are, with a quick feel from a wide area on the face.
Image 1 of 2
Plus, the stability we experienced translated into consistent carry distances, while light misses not only held their line, but carried nearly the entire distance. He is extremely forgiving for his size.
The Wilson D9 Forged is also forgiving, the iron being extremely playable, especially for those with a medium or higher swing speed. Ball flight on well-hit shots was repeatable and consistent, which meant we could be more accurate with our aiming points when swinging well.
Both of these models are high-class performers, almost matching each other in looks, ball-striking experience and on-course performance. When considering the price, the D9 Forged is around $55 per club cheaper, which arguably offers better value, but you get a bit more overall performance from the Ping to justify the higher investment. .
For starters, the consistency offered by the i525 from different lies, plus the option of a Power or Retro spec if you want more or less distance respectively, means there’s plenty of adaptability for s fit your desires for distance and ball flight, while the looks at address will inspire any golfer to commit to the shot.
For the Wilson D9 Forged, this is truly one of the best value offerings in the distance iron category for players. Stunning looks are matched by impressive overall feel and performance – Wilson is not a brand to be overlooked and the D9 Forged is just one of many Wilson golf clubs that mistakenly tend to slip under the radar.
Which one to choose ?
Choose the Ping i525 if…
– You prefer a satin finish
– You want a higher ball flight
– You don’t mind slightly clicky but powerful sound and feel
Choose the Wilson D9 Forged if…
– You prefer a mirror chrome finish
– You favor a soft, forged feel
– You have enough speed to cope with the flatter flight